Testing lending messages with small business owners

American Express

Year

2026

Role

Growth marketer

Category

Evaluative research

Tools

UserTesting, Mural

Year

2026

Role

Growth marketer

Category

Evaluative research

Tools

UserTesting, Mural

Overview

A simpler pricing model raised a new acquisition question

Overview

A simpler pricing model raised a new acquisition question

Overview

A simpler pricing model raised a new acquisition question

American Express Business Line of Credit provides funding for small businesses. As its pricing changed, Product and Marketing wanted to understand how to communicate the offer to prospective customers and support acquisition.

I developed the messaging concepts and research plan for a study comparing flat-fee language with the existing pre-approval message.

Short on time?

Hypothesis

Could simpler pricing become a stronger acquisition message?

Hypothesis

Could simpler pricing become a stronger acquisition message?

Hypothesis

Could simpler pricing become a stronger acquisition message?

The product moved from multiple fee structures to a flat monthly percentage, giving Product and Marketing a new benefit to communicate. We wanted to understand whether leading with clearer pricing could encourage more applications than the existing “You may be pre-approved” message.

I wrote four headline alternatives to explore how customers understood the fees, what value they took from the message, and whether it gave them a compelling reason to apply.

Variant 1

Borrow without any surprise fees

Variant 2

Funding made easy with straightforward fees

Variant 3

Predictable, fixed-fee pricing means no surprises

Variant 4

Funding with straightforward pricing

Research

Testing which message felt clearest and most compelling

Research

Testing which message felt clearest and most compelling

Research

Testing which message felt clearest and most compelling

Study overview

I partnered with UX research on a two-phased mixed-method study.

We used unmoderated testing to narrow for flat-fee messages, then moderated interviews to understand why the strongest messages resonated and how they compare it with the existing control messaging:

Existing message (control)

"You may be pre-approved"

Phase 1: Unmoderated testing

Testing four flat fee variants

Phase 1: Unmoderated testing

Testing four flat fee variants

Phase 1: Unmoderated testing

Testing four flat fee variants

UX Research split 16 business owners with prior lending experience into two groups, each comparing a pair of headlines.

Findings between the two groups

Variant 1 vs. Variant 2

Variant 1 clearly outperformed Variant 2

Variant 1 vs. Variant 2

Variant 1 clearly outperformed Variant 2

Variant 3 vs. Variant 4

"Predictable pricing" and "straightforward pricing" felt similar

Variant 3 vs. Variant 4

"Predictable pricing" and "straightforward pricing" felt similar

Phase 1 takeaway

V1 advanced as the clearest flat-fee message, while V4 moved forward from the second group for deeper moderated testing.

Phase 2: moderated study

Comparing shortlisted pricing messages with pre-approval

Phase 2: moderated study

Comparing shortlisted pricing messages with pre-approval

Phase 2: moderated study

Comparing shortlisted pricing messages with pre-approval

UX Research conducted 30-minute interviews with five new small business owners to compare V1 and V4 with pre-approval messaging, exploring which felt clearer and more compelling.

Findings

Variant 1 vs. Variant 4

Variant 1 remained the stronger flat-fee message

Variant 1 vs. Variant 4

Variant 1 remained the stronger flat-fee message

Flat-fee messaging vs pre-approval

Pre-approval messaging felt like a lower-commitment next step

Flat-fee messaging vs pre-approval

Pre-approval messaging felt like a lower-commitment next step

Phase 2 takeaway

Preferences were mixed: pricing-led and pre-approval messages gave participants different reasons to consider applying.

Recommendations

Use pricing clarity to build understanding without replacing what already works

Recommendations

Use pricing clarity to build understanding without replacing what already works

Recommendations

Use pricing clarity to build understanding without replacing what already works

The study clarified where each message was strongest

The study showed that flat-fee and pre-approval messaging gave customers different reasons to consider applying. The team plans to build on these findings with a live A/B test to understand which approach drives more applications.

Thanks for visiting ⊹ ࣪ ˖

© 2026 Valerie Ma

Let's connect

NEW YORK, NY08:28 PM
Last updated:09/05/2026

Thanks for visiting ⊹ ࣪ ˖

© 2026 Valerie Ma

Let's connect

NEW YORK, NY08:28 PM
Last updated:09/05/2026

Thanks for visiting ⊹ ࣪ ˖

© 2026 Valerie Ma

Let's connect

NEW YORK, NY08:28 PM
Last updated:09/05/2026